This is a blog kept by students of Written Expression IV at ISFD 30. Enjoy!

Monday, July 7, 2014

To Greed, or Not to Greed (review)

Mariana Figueredo
Camila Rico

“Two Greedy Bears”(1976)
Retold by Mirra Ginsburg.
Aladdin Paperbacks.
                                                                                                    
A big round cheese to divide and two bear cubs who want exact equal parts. In this adapted version of a Hungarian Folk Tale, storyteller Mirra Ginsburg brings us the story of two selfish bear cubs (and their two big tummies) who go on an adventure and learn a worthy lesson. Combined with Jose Aruego and Ariane Dewey’s colorful and simple illustrations, Ginsburg succeeds in portraying the values of sharing and being grateful, or more precisely, the consequences of not being so.

Our two little bears are out to see the world, but they find some problems as soon as they leave their home. After some walking, a yummy cheese appears on their way, and a clever fox as well. Arguing and growling, the two bear cubs try to divide the cheese into two equal parts. But pretending to be a friend, from a hidden bush, the fox shows up and offers some help. “Don´t worry,” she said, “I know what to do.” Repeatedly eating more from one piece than the other, the sly one makes sure both bears complain that there is no equality. The more they shout, the more she eats, till finally there are only two tiny crumbs.

Ginsburg plays with a tragicomic sense of greediness, which will make readers feel sympathetic to the two poor bears. Thus, text and pictures are organized in such a way that makes both equally important to convey meaning and to create a humorous atmosphere around the problems these two little bears face in their journey.

Funny and straightforward, Two Greedy Bears wisely exemplifies how greed leads to losses and brings little bears to tears.


6 comments:

  1. I love your review! Great title! I think that the content is perfect. Very well done girls!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like the title also! very original!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love the way you write!! The title is very catching indeed :)
    I don't agree with you about the reader's feelings towards the bears. In my opinion, they deserved to be cheated.
    I find the story slightly inspired by the poems that José Hernandez wrote in 1872
    "Brothers should stick together
    In good or in stormy weather;
    If fighting starts among insiders
    They'll easily be beaten by outsiders
    Who'll blow them away like a feather"
    Anyway, the story is a good tool to teach children that no matter how unbearable their siblings are, they certainly would meet worse people during their lives.
    So,DO NOT FIGHT!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your review is written in a lovely way!! The message about not to fight is clear and direct!!.Congratulations!!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Beautiful review! Perfect story to read out to the kids of the house!

    ReplyDelete
  6. You chose a great title, and I agree with the message you've developed.
    The first sentence sounds a little out of place to me, but maybe, this happens because I don't know too much about the order of information in a review.
    Good job!

    ReplyDelete